Archived: The Case for Comprehensive Immigration Reform


Across America, nearly everyone agrees that the current immigration system is broken. So if the system is broken, why do we continue pouring money into it? Instead, we should take this historic opportunity to fix it.

Many politicians are saying that they want to address the root causes of our immigration situation, but they go on to talk only about increased enforcement. Of course, we are a nation of laws and the rule of law should be upheld. But experience and common sense show us that merely building a bigger wall won’t work because enforcement alone does not deal with the root causes. If we’re going to address the causes of immigration, we need to have a serious conversation about factors like American trade policy (including NAFTA) and the lack of opportunity in many “sending” countries. When NAFTA went into effect in the mid-1990’s, its unfair trade provisions allowed U.S.-subsidized corn to flood the Mexican market, bankrupting nearly 2 million Mexican corn farmers virtually overnight. This major economic disaster had a big impact on immigration into the U.S. from Mexico.

The bottom line is that Congress and the President basically have three options for addressing immigration – and only one of them will work. 1) Allow the current immigration mess to deteriorate further, a prospect that frustrates the vast majority the American people. 2) Hold out for the ugly fantasy that we are going to get rid of 12 million undocumented immigrants, a prospect as unrealistic as it is un-American. 3) Move forward with a comprehensive plan that restores the rule of law, gets people in the system, makes employers play by the rules, and creates a stable, sustainable and legal system of immigration.

Since we’re not going to deport 12 million people, we need comprehensive immigration reform that includes a path to citizenship in order to assimilate new Americans. We already know that building a bigger wall won’t help. We’ve tried that for the last few years with nothing to show for it. What we need is an orderly system that works for both immigrants and our country.

Comprehensive reform is the only practical and sensible way to ensure that all workers are here legally, unscrupulous employers cannot undercut their honest competitors, fairness is restored to the labor market, and enforceability and justice are restored to the rule of law. It will lift wages for workers, restore tax fairness, and create a level playing field for law-abiding employers.

Despite the clamoring of a noisy minority, polling data consistently shows that American voters support comprehensive reform over an enforcement-only approach. A recent national poll found that when voters are given the details of comprehensive reform, 86 percent support Congress passing comprehensive reform, while only 7 percent strongly oppose the plan.

So what should comprehensive immigration reform look like? The solution to our current broken system must include:

—The reunification of families and preservation of our family immigration system;
—A way for people to get in the system with legal status so they get on a path to citizenship, learn English, and become part of society;
—A coherent and fair legal system that respects the value of due process;
—A logical, viable system for regulating legal immigration; and
—Effective, humane border and interior enforcement that respects everyone’s rights and keeps communities safe without forcing people into society’s shadows.

We know that Americans do not want our families getting torn apart. We do not want our workers getting abused. We do not want a trap door in the minimum wage. The American people want a practical, commonsense solution that’s fair to everyone. Difficult problems demand strong leadership, and the people of North Carolina are looking to Washington to put our immigration system back on the right track.

As members of the faith community, we believe that we have the opportunity to fix our nation’s broken immigration system and uphold our deepest values at the same time. The command to welcome the “stranger” echoes in our ears as immigrant families and workers are living in a state of fear due to increased raids, deportations and anti-immigrant sentiment. Our religious traditions call us to love our neighbor as ourselves, and we believe this applies to immigrants as much as anyone else.

Reed is executive director of the North Carolina Council of Churches, an ecumenical, non-partisan, statewide organization. Liu-Beers is a program associate with the North Carolina Council of Churches and works on immigration issues. Copyright (C) 2009 by the North Carolina Editorial Forum. 9/09

Posted - Copyright © 2022 Eastern Group Publications, Inc.

Print This Post Print This Post


  1. Well an immigration reform sounds OK for everybody but for José will be hard to get used to pay taxes every year, go to the ER and get a bill in the mail among other things. You know what? after twelve years of getting away with all this, who needs more a reform JOSE or SAM? Don’t force your brain

  2. it’s foolish to believe that someone would chose illegal path if there were legal options.
    @reverend if you really immigrated as you say, you should know what’s the process like. it’s not something that person without specific qualifications, lots of money, family ready to sponsor or tons of luck could get done.
    it’s obvious that there is something wrong with the law if so many people are breaking it. its natural. the same applies to traffic laws. our speed limits are ridiculously low so people speed all the time. that should be changed too.
    laws are supposed to protect people and to make order in society not to compel. some laws are not good, and they are usually disobeyed by majority and later changed (think prohibition).

  3. If NAFTA is the root cause then the simplest solution is revoke NAFTA.
    The current immigration law is probably better than any new law that congress could come up with, the broken part of the current law is the fact that it is not enforced.
    The arguments presented make very little sense much like it makes very little sense to allow 12 million plus law breakers to become U.S. Citizens.

  4. Reverend Reed,

    I can understand your position about this topic, which can be so heated on both sides of the issue. But I believe that you missed a few good arguments for the enforcement of immigration law. It exists for the safety and security of our nation and it’s citizens. Because of those coming here illegally, identities are stolen, at the expense of the innocent. Tell me father, what would Jesus say to those who broke the 8th commandment?

    You spoke of what Americans want up above, but you also failed to mention that Americans also want the law to be respected. As for immigration, there is a legal process by which those can seek legal status, but willingly avoid it. I personally came here from another country legally, out of respect for this country and it’s laws. I had to wait, like others, but I did and am here with full citizenship.

    Those who come here father, are sowing a seed of deceit, by breaking the law, and you know as well as I do, one day they shall reap the reward of that seed. That could be prison, deportation, or separation of family. These people you speak of, know full well they are coming here against the law, so I have no pity for them if they reap the consequences of that.

    You reap what you sow my friend, it is Biblical law, people need not be surprised when the Lord gives them what is coming to them, be it good or bad.

Leave A Reply

Comments are intended to further discussion on the article topic. EGPNews reserves the right to not publish, edit or remove comments that contain vulgarities, foul language, personal attacks, racists, sexist, homophobic or other offensive terminology or that contain solicitations, spam, or that threaten harm of any sort. EGPNews will not approve comments that call for or applaud the death, injury or illness of any person, regardless of their public status. Questions regarding this policy should be e-mailed to